Assurex E&O Plus | Is Theft of Property in an Undescribed Building Covered?
21779
wp-singular,post-template-default,single,single-post,postid-21779,single-format-standard,wp-theme-bridge,qode-quick-links-1.0,ajax_fade,page_not_loaded,,qode-theme-ver-11.1,qode-theme-bridge,wpb-js-composer js-comp-ver-5.1.1,vc_responsive

Is Theft of Property in an Undescribed Building Covered?

Is Theft of Property in an Undescribed Building Covered?

An insured operated an open-lot business covered under an ISO Commercial Property Building and Personal Property Coverage Form. The insured stored a substantial amount of business personal property in an enclosed shed on the premises. Because the shed had little value, the insured chose not to insure it.

Thieves later broke into the shed and stole $25,000 worth of business personal property. The claims adjuster denied the claim, stating that the property was not covered because it was in an undescribed building. The adjuster added that the property would have been covered if it had been stored in the open. Is that correct?

Generally, yes.

Many businesses have small or low-value structures on their premises. These may include storage sheds, detached garages, maintenance buildings, pump houses, barns, or other outbuildings. Although the buildings themselves may have little replacement value, they can contain significant amounts of business personal property.  That creates an important coverage issue under the Building and Personal Property Coverage Form.

Where Is Business Personal Property Covered?

Business personal property is generally covered when it is located:

  • In or on the described building
  • In the open
  • In a vehicle within 100 feet of the described building or within 100 feet of the described premises, whichever distance is greater

The key phrase is “described building.” Business personal property stored inside an enclosed structure is not necessarily treated the same as property located outdoors. If the structure containing the property is not identified on the policy, coverage may not apply, even when the structure is located on the insured premises.

In this example, the stolen property was inside an enclosed shed. Because the shed was not described in the declarations, the business personal property stored inside it would not be covered. Had the same property been stored in the open within the applicable 100-foot area, it would have fallen within the policy’s coverage provisions, subject to the policy’s exclusions, limits, and deductible.

The Building Does Not Have to Be Insured

A common misunderstanding is that the shed must be insured for its full value for the contents to be covered. That is not necessarily the case.

The building must be described, but the insured does not have to purchase coverage on the building itself. The insured could identify the shed on the policy while selecting no coverage, or a minimal amount of coverage, for the structure. This allows the business personal property inside the building to be properly covered under the policy.

Other Coverage Consequences

Failing to describe the building can create additional gaps. Debris removal coverage generally applies only to covered property. If the building itself is not covered, debris removal of the personal property in the building may not be available.

Similarly, the Preservation of Property provision may not cover contents moved from an uninsured building to protect them from a covered peril.

The lesson is straightforward: whenever business personal property is stored in an outbuilding, the building should be specifically described—even if the insured does not want coverage for the building itself. A quick review of every structure on the premises can prevent a significant and unexpected coverage dispute.